jackiedoherty.org

News, schools, and views from a uniquely Lowell perspective
19th May 2009

New plan proposes closing Rogers School

posted in Education, Money Matters, school committee |

With more bad news on the fiscal front and the Lowell Public Schools likely facing $8 million in cuts next year, the Facilities Subcommittee and other members met last night to discuss closing schools to save money. The administration proposed a new plan (Plan B) to close the Rogers Middle School, moving the strand of Portuguese-speaking students and their teachers to the Butler School, and dispersing the remaining students to middle schools throughout the district where space is available. The plan will save the district $3.2 million up front with additional savings in reduced rental fees possible by moving the Family Literacy Center, Adult Education, and portions of Central Office to the vacated Rogers School site. Since some middle schools are currently under enrolled, closing the Rogers School will not have a major impact on class sizes, which typically run about 25 students at the middle-school level. (Previously, the administration had proposed a plan to close the Moody School, sending those elementary students to the Bartlett Community Partnership School while moving the Bartlett middle-school students to the Stoklosa School, and using the old Moody building for administrative offices. That plan would have saved the district about $1.2 million.) According to the administration, Plan B not only saves more money, but it also displaces less students, and provides the district with a better site for offices, family literacy, and adult education as well as a centralized location in the city. The full committee will consider this cost-saving recommendation, among others, during Budget Hearings, which begin May 27 in Council Chambers at 7 pm. Closing the Rogers School—a thriving community of caring educators, students and families—is but one painful step in a long road of recommended cuts required to educate our students with $8 million less in revenue next year.  

There are currently 17 responses to “New plan proposes closing Rogers School”

Why not let us know what you think by adding your own comment! Your opinion is as valid as anyone elses, so come on... let us know what you think.

  1. 1 On May 19th, 2009, Ingrid said:

    I go to the rogers and i love that school ive been there for 2 years and i want to go to 8 th grade there too and i really don’t want that school, to close and if i it does im going to cry so much

  2. 2 On May 19th, 2009, Warren said:

    For the the first time, we don’t have the “extra cash”, that the “school side has always seen”.. The “school side”, is being treated like “the rest of the city’s budget”, sign of the time.

  3. 3 On May 19th, 2009, the "conservative" said:

    The “school side” , should be treated like “any other budget in the city”. The cut backs to the city’s services are at a critical level as it is, and more is coming. So, where is the money coming from, the tax payers, didn’t Wall Street get us enough the past year and half.

  4. 4 On May 19th, 2009, the conservative said:

    The “school side” of the budget should be treated like “anyone else”. At this point, every department is down to their critical level and “counting”. It just can’t be found and needs to be distributed to make a “balanced budget”. When will the tax payer “see a break”, or will Wall Street just take the rest of what little we have. I don’t want to read another paper or turn on the TV, just tell me when it’s over !!

  5. 5 On May 20th, 2009, Jackie said:

    I don’t know what “extra cash” Warren is talking about. Since 2003, the Lowell school district has eliminated 400 positions–that’s less paraprofessionals, teachers, librarians, etc for our students. We will continue to look for cost-saving reforms and cuts that will have the least impact on the quality of education our children receive (not an easy proposition when you’re facing an $8 million shortfall). In the meantime, don’t discount the disruption closing a school causes on the whole system, from teachers getting bumped to different schools and grade levels, to students and families heartbroken to have to leave their school community as Ingrid notes. It is a difficult time and there are no good choices.

  6. 6 On May 20th, 2009, Student at the Rogers School said:

    Please please dont close the school it means everything to the
    students there including me, kids go first than money. If you close
    it down everybody will be in tears and I been there for almost 4
    years. Just say that it is going to be so sad to see the E.N Rogers
    Middle School close.

  7. 7 On May 21st, 2009, samantha (: said:

    I currently go to and love the Rogers school. I have no idea what I’d do if I have to start a whole new school year, 180 days, in a different place with different people when I’m already used to all these people and places and actually consider most of my fellow classmates family or really close friends. To me the Rogers is like a second home, I come here all the time, and yet I’m not even close to ready to give it up, considering the fact that everybody here is part of my life, now. I do and alway will love the Rogers and would be devistated if anything ever happened to it.Please, if you can (and I’m not saying that you actually have to) help us save our school. Protest, we did and hopefully that worked. (:

  8. 8 On May 21st, 2009, Joan H said:

    It is about time that the School side of the budget gets the same treatment as the rest of the city. At a time when everyone is hurting they need to feel the pain as much as the rest of the city. They have always seemed to believe that they are above others, especially with raises at a time when everyone else is cutting back. I was surprised to learn that some of out city schools are operating at 2/3 capacity, so it makes sence to close a couple. No matter which one(s) is/are chosen, there will be an outcry from that school’s “community”.

  9. 9 On May 21st, 2009, Travon Alexander said:

    We all have one question, why is it our school. Why cant the school committee distribute the unfairness equally among the schools in lowell. We all think this proposal is non-sense. thank you for your time. PLEASE DONT SHUT US DOWN

  10. 10 On May 21st, 2009, Kimlmlu said:

    What cuts are being made in all the other departments and what programs have been cut city wide? The schools, police, and fire should be the last hit. I want to hear about the other “hit’s”!

  11. 11 On May 21st, 2009, Jackie said:

    I don’t know what cuts the city is planning, and we won’t know until their budget process begins–probably in the next few weeks, but I can tell you they are also facing significant cuts.

  12. 12 On May 22nd, 2009, Lorraine Cordeiro said:

    It does not seem like all options have been exhausted prior to discussion of school closings. The last thing on the agenda should be a school closing – change for middle school students is a difficult process. Rogers has had great success at parent involvement (I would opt to say better than any other school in Lowell). Parents cram into the building for events and meet-the-teacher events. It’s a successful model in Lowell. To recreate such a model would take years – particularly among a disadvantaged student population. We cannot argue that Rogers serves the poorest students and families in Lowell. If it’s working, what are our other options.

    Thanks Jackie for all your hard work.
    Lorraine

  13. 13 On May 23rd, 2009, Jackie said:

    Thanks for your comments Lorraine, and I agree with you: the Rogers is a good school with a history of providing a strong learning community for many of our neediest students. In terms of whether all options were exhausted by the administration, all I can tell you is how it was presented to us and what factors were key. (I’m pasting from a comment I made on another post because it speaks to this issue.)
    It’s horrible to close any school and it sends a ripple of disruption across the district that is felt for years, but the decision of which one to close is based on several factors: primary being displacing the least number of students without adversely impacting class sizes and generating the most significant savings. Due to its central location near public transportation and the decent shape of its facility, the Rogers(unfortunately for them) also best meets the criteria for additional savings as a good site to locate school administration offices, the Parent Information Center, adult education, and the Family Literacy Center, bringing the total savings up to $4 million ($3.2 million from closing school plus $800K in rental savings). When you’re looking at a total of $9.5 million in cuts, this option must be considered.

  14. 14 On June 2nd, 2009, The Obvious said:

    I was amused by Regina Faticanti’s sob statement on Saturday about how “the discussion of race never, ever came up” when deciding to close the Rogers School. I was also amused by Bud Caufield’s quick warning to the principal about “crossing a fine line” because he mentioned the obvious. OF COURSE nobody with a brain would say aloud “why don’t we close down the school who’s parents and community would least likely speak up”. Since when did people become so sensitive when discussing the topic of *gasp* racism? Let’s just face it, racism still exists in this city. The Rogers School is a progressive school that has proven to narrow the achievement gap that plagues this city, and will continue to plague this city, as we continue to take advantage of the disadvantaged.

    I

  15. 15 On June 4th, 2009, Jackie said:

    I was at those subcommittee meetings and I can tell you the recommendation to close the Rogers School was based on most money saved with the least number of students disrupted. It was not an option any of us relished, but it was the one that made the most sense for the district. We are an immigrant city with diverse students and degrees of poverty at all our schools.

  16. 16 On June 10th, 2009, Nathan Pang said:

    Hmm, what to say first. Ah yes, this is very unfair. I mean, why the E.N rogers. I’m not trying to sound selfish but there’s a difference in the budget between the Rogers school and any other school? I mean c’mon. It’s a shame all the 5th,6th,and 7th graders don’t get to graduate at a school they really like. With all their friends. Laying teachers off their jobs? How selfish. Kids education also requires fun, and friends. If they are forced to go to another school with no one they know, how can they be expected to learn if they are making fun of or have no one to talk to. It’s a shame really.

    Sincerely, Student of the E.N Rogers, Vannarath Pang.

  17. 17 On June 11th, 2009, Jackie said:

    Thanks for writing, and it is a shame that the Rogers School students will need to transfer to another middle school where they will make new friends. They will all end up at the high school together. We closed the Rogers rather than any other middle school primarily because of its building and the other opportunities for savings it afforded us (in rental property we no longer need downtown) and because it disrupted the least number of students for the most savings. I know that doesn’t make it fair, but it does make it logical.

  • Blogroll

  • Contact Us

  • Education Links

  • Local Groups

  • Local media