jackiedoherty.org

News, schools, and views from a uniquely Lowell perspective
30th April 2007

Opera opinions

posted in Art |

I would love to hear what others thought of the Cambodian opera that premiered in Lowell this weekend.

 I loved the opening scene when the monk says “you must listen to my story” and describes Cambodia in 1963, peaceful and tolerant, then ties it in with the murder of JFK. For my generation, it is almost a cliche to ask someone where you were when JFK was killed. It was the first significant event of my life. I was in first grade and my teacher was crying!  That makes a huge impression on a 6 year-old.  When the monk mentions the day that the Khmer Rouge fell upon Cambodia, in April of 1975, then falls to his knees, no more needs to be said about the horrors that followed.

Some of my favorite moments were:  the song about having “no mothers” and the accompanying dance where a mother is teaching her daughter the intricate Cambodian dance forms; the recurring song “That’s the way love goes”; the moment at the end, when Dara reappears in a monk’s saffron robes and embraces Sam; the scene between Bopha, her sister and Khan, where we see how the family dynamics have evolved out of the horrors of the past; the older monk, and what he is able to teach the younger generation about compassion. I felt like the opera hinged on memory:  some of the most poignant moments were when Sam remembered his father playing the buffalo horn, or when Dara reminded Sam of when they were in the refugee camps together. And yet, there is the sense of how much memory has been lost because of the Khmer Rouge.

While the love story was not that compelling and some of the character motivations were not easily understood, these problems seemed less important as the story progressed.  

There is currently one response to “Opera opinions”

Why not let us know what you think by adding your own comment! Your opinion is as valid as anyone elses, so come on... let us know what you think.

  1. 1 On May 8th, 2007, Anonymous said:

    I thought the opera was a mess and overly melodramatic. The story of the making of the opera (as told by the Lowell Sun, Boston Globe and NPR) was far more interesting then the production itself. I’m surprised that even with all the time and money put into this that the opera resembled a corny high school musical. I agree with the Boston Globe, which stated that the plot was implausible and underdeveloped, much of the music was jarring and implausible, and “by trying to please everybody ‘Elephants’ leaves a muddled message.” And it was disappointing that the majority of the cast wasn’t Cambodian and that 90% of the dialogue and music was in English. I also heard that the Cambodian subtitles on the screen above the stage were poorly done and went by too fast to read.

    There are much better examples of meshing “east with west” done by the Cambodian-American community in Lowell. (such as the Angkor Dance Troupe’s mixing of modern dance with traditional Cambodian dance and the defunct hip-hop group Seiasia).

  • Blogroll

  • Contact Us

  • Education Links

  • Local Groups

  • Local media